|
Welcome to the Best Emerson Site
on the Web!
Find out how the Second Amendment
Foundation and gun rights allies forced the government to recognize the Second Amendment as an individual right!
Table of Contents
1) Emerson Supreme Court Information
2) Emerson 5th Circuit Information
3) Initial Emerson Decision
4) Media Coverage of the Emerson Case
5) Opponent's reaction to Emerson Case
6) SAF involvement in Emerson Case
7) Miscellaneous Emerson Info
8) Pro-Gun Ownership Briefs
9) Related law review articles
Dr. Timothy Emerson is a gun owner who found himself in the middle of the national debate
over the meaning of the Second Amendment. During a divorce, a local judge issued a standard divorce-related restraining
order. These orders are generally to keep both parties from selling mutually owned property. However, federal law
also prohibits the possession of a firearm while the subject of a restraining order.
Dr. Emerson was in possession of several rifles and a handgun when his wife notified police.
He was subsequently arrested for violating federal firearms laws. He defended himself saying that he had a constitutionally
protected right to possess a firearm.
Initially, in 1999, U.S. district judge Sam Cummings agreed with Dr. Emerson and dismissed
the charges. The case then proceeded to the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals, where the Circuit recognized an individual
right to keep and bear arms, but held that Dr. Emerson was still subject to reasonable restrictions of that right.
The case was then appealed to the Supreme Court of the United States, which refused to hear it, and sent it back
to the original judge for trial.
Dr. Emerson was eventually found guilty, and was sentenced. However, his sentence has been
stayed pending Dr. Emerson's latest appeal to the Fifth Circuit. Despite Dr. Emerson's personal misfortunes, this
case was a major victory for gun rights supporters. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the Second Amendment
was an individual right, which is something that gun rights supporters have been fighting for.
Emerson Supreme
Court Information:
Petition for Writ of Certiorari
Governments
response admitting that the Second Amendment is an individual right
Ashcroft memo on the Emerson Decision
Status of case from the Supreme
Court website
Fifth Circuit Decision:
5th Circuit Decision-With William Garwood (Reagan), Harold DeMoss Jr. (Bush), and Robert Parker (Clinton) for judges.
Emerson En Banc
Good and the Bad of
the Oral Arguments -- Excerpts from the three judge panel hearing
SAF Emerson Decision
Release
Emerson Appeal
Initial Decision
Review Governments Stinging District Court Defeat Here
View amended opinion with hyperlinks
Judgement
District Court of Northern Texas Homepage
Biography of Judge Sam R. Cummings
Year of Birth: 1944
Began Service: 1987
Appointed By: President Ronald Reagan
Education: Texas Tech University 1967 BBA with high honors; Baylor
University School of Law 1970 JD, cum laude
Legal Practice: Partner, Culton, Morgan, Britain & White, Amarillo 1970 - 1987
Current Memberships: State Bar of Texas and Texas Bar Foundation
Professional: Board Certified in Civil Trial Law, Texas Board of Legal Specialization
Media Coverage of the Decision
Lubbock Avalanche-Journal
Washington Times
Free Market.net
Foxnews.com
Washington Times
CNN
Newsmax
The Independent Institute
The Wall Street
Journal
George Will
National Review
Opponents Reaction
VPC Anti-gun letter to DOJ
VPC loss spin
Response
to VPC propaganda
Potowmac Institute Spin on Emerson
Brady/Handgun Control
release, at least approaching honesty
SAF involvement
SAF Amicus Brief
SAF letter from David Young listed in SAF brief
Article
on David Young from KeepandBearArms.com
SAF Legal Defense Fund
SAF Emerson Decision
Release
Pro Gun Ownership Briefs
Gun Owner's Foundation Brief
Congress of Racial Equality Brief
Independence Institute's
Brief
Ethan Allen Institute and Heartland Institute Brief
Citizens Committee for the Right to Keep and Bear Arms
Brief
Women Against Gun Control, Southern States Police Benevolent
Association, Jews for the Preservation of Firearm Ownership Brief
Texas Justice Foundation's Brief
Texas State Rifle Association's Brief
Academics for the Second Amendment Brief
Law Enforcement Alliance of America's Brief
NRA Brief
State of Alabama Brief
Miscellaneous
Selected
quotes from Emerson Decision
Government
again in the Haney case admits the 2nd Amend is an individual right
An attorney's
take on the ruling
Another attorney's thoughts
Stupid Quotes from
the Emerson Case
View the restraining order that started
it all
BATF Form that Emerson signed
A Primer on
the Individual Right to Keep and Bear Arms
More coverage of Emerson from KeepandBearArms.com
Ashcroft's Second Amendment Justice Department
Memo
|